{"schemaVersion":1,"research":true,"symbol":"lii","name":"Lennox International","topic":"moat","path":"/stock/lii/moat","status":"published","version":8,"updatedAt":"2026-10-19T21:10:20.173Z","locked":false,"publicFairValue":false,"fairValue":null,"moat":{"verdict":"uncertain","summary":"Lennox has an established dealer and stores channel, service capabilities, brands and product-development resources. These are current operating strengths, but the passages do not establish durable switching costs, a sustained brand premium or superior unit costs. Favorable price/mix supported profits despite inflation and falling residential volumes, although product mix materially contributed. Standard sales terms demonstrate bounded repricing freedom. Commercial growth offsets residential weakness, leaving durable economic protection unproven rather than demonstrating a uniformly weak competitive position.","advantages":[{"mechanism":"switching_costs","claim":"The direct dealer channel, parts availability and national-account services provide customer touchpoints that could support repeat purchasing. Their existence is demonstrated; economically significant switching friction is not.","durability":"The channel is established, but its revenue share does not measure dealer retention, exclusivity or the cost of changing suppliers.","risks":"Lennox explicitly describes distribution as a low-barrier business. Residential volume contraction demonstrates demand exposure, although it does not establish customer defections. Carrier Global Corporation also discloses distribution and lifecycle service capabilities.","invalidation":"The switching-cost thesis would be undermined by persistent dealer departures, national-account losses or evidence that customers routinely change suppliers without meaningful cost or service disruption.","competitors":["Carrier Global Corporation","Trane Technologies plc"],"evidenceIds":["e1","e2","e3","e4"],"counterEvidenceIds":["e5","e6","e7","e8"]},{"mechanism":"intangible_assets","claim":"Brands, patents and engineering capabilities support product differentiation. The catalog does not demonstrate a persistent brand premium or technology exclusion sufficient to establish a moat.","durability":"Maintaining differentiation requires continued development. No single patent is material, and competing suppliers offer branded equipment and services.","risks":"Competition includes availability, efficiency, reliability, service and price. Favorable realized price/mix is partly a product-transition benefit and cannot establish brand pricing power by itself.","invalidation":"The differentiation thesis would be undermined by sustained discounting, loss of dealer preference, repeated product failures or comparable competitor products eliminating any demonstrated performance or ownership-cost benefit.","competitors":["Carrier Global Corporation","Trane Technologies plc","Paloma Industries, Inc."],"evidenceIds":["e9","e10","e11","e12"],"counterEvidenceIds":["e8","e13","e14","e15"]}],"evidence":[{"id":"e1","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"Business / Marketing and Distribution","excerpt":"We distribute our “Lennox” brands in a company-owned process directly to independent dealers that install these heating and cooling products."},{"id":"e2","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"Business / Lennox Stores product availability","excerpt":"and Canada. These stores provide an easy access solution for contractors and independent dealers to obtain universal service and replacement parts, supplies, convenience items, tools, Lennox equipment and OEM parts."},{"id":"e3","sourceId":"filing-2","location":"Revenue Recognition / Building Climate Solutions services","excerpt":"We also provide installation, service and preventive maintenance for HVAC national account customers in the United States and Canada; manufacture curb, curb adapters, drop box diffusers; offer HVAC recycling and salvage services; and focus on multi-family HVAC replacement for expired mechanical assets."},{"id":"e4","sourceId":"filing-2","location":"Revenue Recognition / first-half direct-channel revenue share","excerpt":"For the six months ended June 30, 2026 and 2025, direct sales represented 73% and 74% of revenues, respectively, and sales to independent distributors represented the remainder."},{"id":"e5","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"Risk Factors / low-barrier distribution business","excerpt":"If we are unable to continue to execute our strategy, whether due to changes in economic conditions, a failure to anticipate changing customer needs, entry of new competitors into the low-barrier distribution business, or for any other reason, our revenue could decline, which could in turn adversely impact our product pull-through and our ability to grow revenue."},{"id":"e6","sourceId":"filing-2","location":"MD&A / first-half Home Comfort Solutions results","excerpt":"Losses (gains) and other expenses, net for the six months ended June 30, 2026 and 2025 included the following (in millions):\n(3.5)\nThe following table presents our Home Comfort Solutions segment's net sales and profit for the six months ended June 30, 2026 and 2025 (dollars in millions):\nDifference\n% Change\n(145.1)\n(8)\n308.3 \n375.9 \n(67.6)\n(18)\n% of net sales\n19.4 \n21.7 \n Net sales decreased 8% for the six months ended June 30, 2026 as compared to the same period in 2025 primarily due to a 16% decrease in sales volumes, which was partially offset by a 6% increase from favorable mix and price and a 2% increase in sales volumes from completed acquisitions."},{"id":"e7","sourceId":"filing-13","location":"Carrier competitor disclosure / distribution channels","excerpt":"Products and controls, services and systems are sold directly to building contractors and owners and indirectly through joint ventures, independent sales representatives, distributors, wholesalers, dealers and retail outlets."},{"id":"e8","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"Business / named heating and cooling competitors","excerpt":"•Heating & Cooling Products - Carrier Global Corporation (Carrier, Bryant, Payne, Tempstar, Comfortmaker, Heil, Arcoaire, KeepRite, Day & Night); Trane Technologies plc (Trane, American Standard, Ameristar, Oxbox, RunTru); Paloma Industries, Inc."},{"id":"e9","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"Business / engineering and technology organization","excerpt":"We operate an engineering and technology organization that focuses on new technology invention, product development, product quality improvements and process enhancements, including our development of next-generation control systems as well as heating, cooling and refrigeration products that include some of the most efficient products in their respective categories."},{"id":"e10","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"Business / Patents and Trademarks","excerpt":"Patents and Trademarks\nWe hold numerous patents that relate to the design and use of our products."},{"id":"e11","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"Business / trademark ownership and protection","excerpt":"We own or license several trademarks and service marks we consider important in the marketing of our products and services, and we protect our marks through national registrations and common law rights."},{"id":"e12","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"MD&A / 2025 consolidated sales volume and price/mix","excerpt":"Impairment on assets held for sale\nLoss (gain) on sale of businesses\n(0.3)\n1,041.5 \n20.0 \n1,040.4 \n19.5 \n791.5 \n15.9 \n15.2 \n11.9 \nYear Ended December 31, 2025 Compared to Year Ended December 31, 2024 - Consolidated Results\nNet Sales\nNet sales decreased 3% in 2025 compared to 2024 as lower sales volumes of 13% were partially offset by favorable price and mix of 9% and a 1% increase in sales volumes due to our fourth quarter acquisition of Duro Dyne and Supco."},{"id":"e13","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"Business / absence of a material individual patent","excerpt":"We consider these patents important, but no single patent is material to the overall conduct of our business."},{"id":"e14","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"Business / competitive factors","excerpt":"The most significant competitive factors we face are product availability, reliability, energy efficiency, product performance, service, and price, with the relative importance of these factors varying among customer applications."},{"id":"e15","sourceId":"filing-9","location":"Full-year 2025 results / new-product mix contribution","excerpt":"Profit improvement can be attributed to $356 million of mix/price benefits, driven primarily by new product mix; and $56 million improvement in other costs, including selling expense."},{"id":"e16","sourceId":"filing-2","location":"MD&A / first-half consolidated results and price/mix","excerpt":"Year-to-Date through June 30, 2026 Compared to Year-to-Date through June 30, 2025 - Consolidated Results The following table provides a summary of our financial results, including information presented as a percentage of net sales: For the Six Months Ended June 30, Dollars (in millions) Percent Change Fav/(Unfav) Percent of Sales 2026 2025 2026 2025 Net sales $ 2,680.4 $ 2,573.5 4.2 % 100.0 % 100.0 % Cost of goods sold 1,789.6 1,715.1 (4.3) 66.8 66.6 Gross profit 890.8 858.4 3.8 33.2 33.4 Selling, general and administrative expenses 368.3 344.6 (6.9) 13.7 13.4 (Gains) losses and other expenses, net 4.6 0.1 (4,500.0) 0.2 — Income from equity method investments (0.6) (3.3) (81.8) — (0.1) Operating income $ 518.5 $ 517.0 0.3 % 19.3 % 20.1 % Net Sales Net sales increased 4% for the six months ended June 30, 2026 as compared to the same period in 2025, primarily due to a 5% increase from favorable mix and price and a 5% increase in sales volumes from completed acquisitions, which were partially offset by a 6% decrease in sales volumes."},{"id":"e17","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"MD&A / 2025 gross-margin bridge","excerpt":"Gross profit margin increased 290 bps from higher price and favorable mix, which was partially offset by 160 bps from higher products costs and 120 bps from higher freight and distribution costs."},{"id":"e18","sourceId":"filing-2","location":"MD&A / first-half gross-margin bridge and tariff refunds","excerpt":"Gross margins decreased 170 bps from higher product costs, primarily reflecting inflation and factory under absorption, net of $30 million in tariff refunds, 40 bps from higher freight and distribution costs, and 20 bps from miscellaneous 24 costs, which were partially offset by 180 bps from favorable mix and price and 30 bps from completed acquisitions."},{"id":"e19","sourceId":"filing-7","location":"Second-quarter release / management account of implemented pricing","excerpt":"Pricing actions implemented in response to inflationary and tariff pressures largely offset those impacts, while earlier than expected tariff refunds provided a benefit during the quarter."},{"id":"e20","sourceId":"filing-2","location":"MD&A / replacement-business demand","excerpt":"A substantial portion of the sales in each of our business segments is attributable to replacement business, with the balance comprised of new construction business."},{"id":"e21","sourceId":"filing-7","location":"Second-quarter release / national accounts, replacement and service growth","excerpt":"Organic revenue growth of 15% was driven by strong execution with national account customers, healthy emergency replacement activity, and growth in service offerings, while acquisitions added 9% to revenue growth."},{"id":"e22","sourceId":"filing-15","location":"US goods sales terms / quotations and prices; retrieved October 19, 2026","excerpt":"4. Quotations and Prices; Taxes . Prices in quotations made by Seller are subject to change without notice, and all quotations expire and become invalid if not accepted within thirty (30) days from the date of issue, unless otherwise noted by Seller in writing."},{"id":"e23","sourceId":"filing-15","location":"US goods sales terms / price-adjustment right; retrieved October 19, 2026","excerpt":"Seller reserves the right to adjust prices at any time, including where due to delays, shortage, or increased costs related to materials, components, labor, transportation, freight, regulatory compliance, or other events outside of Seller’s control."},{"id":"e24","sourceId":"filing-15","location":"US goods sales terms / definitive-contract precedence; retrieved October 19, 2026","excerpt":"In the event Purchaser and Seller have executed a definitive contract relating to the Goods purchased (a “Definitive Contract”), then the terms and conditions set forth in such contract shall supersede any conflicting terms and conditions set forth herein for as long as such contract is in effect and not terminated or expired."},{"id":"e25","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"MD&A / annual operating cash generation","excerpt":"Net Cash Provided By Operating Activities - Net cash provided by operating activities decreased $188 million to $758 million in 2025 compared to $946 million in 2024."},{"id":"e26","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"MD&A / acquisition spending","excerpt":"Net Cash Used In Investing Activities - Net cash used in investing activities increased $481 million from 2024 to 2025 primarily due to $545 million related to our acquisition of Duro Dyne and Supco, which was partially offset by lower capital expenditures."},{"id":"e27","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"MD&A / capital expenditures","excerpt":"Capital expenditures were $119 million, $164 million and $250 million in 2025, 2024 and 2023, respectively."},{"id":"e28","sourceId":"filing-2","location":"Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows / first-half spending, distributions and borrowing","excerpt":"AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS (Unaudited) (Amounts in millions) For the Six Months Ended June 30, 2026 2025 Cash flows from operating activities: Net income $ 386.2 $ 403.5 Adjustments to reconcile net income to net cash provided by operating activities: Income from equity method investments (0.6) (3.3) Provision for credit losses 2.5 0.8 Unrealized losses (gains), net on derivative contracts 3.7 (0.3) Stock-based compensation expense 12.1 14.5 Depreciation and amortization 61.8 52.4 Deferred income taxes 7.3 (8.8) Pension expense 2.0 2.1 Pension contributions (0.5) (0.6) Changes in assets and liabilities, net of effects of acquisitions and divestitures: Accounts and notes receivable (345.2) (205.9) Inventories (7.0) (300.7) Other current assets (7.8) 4.4 Accounts payable 93.5 88.2 Accrued expenses (5.0) (52.7) Income taxes payable and receivable, net (20.4) 55.2 Leases, net 4.8 4.4 Other, net 0.7 (2.2) Net cash provided by operating activities 188.1 51.0 Cash flows from investing activities: Proceeds from the disposal of property, plant and equipment 1.4 0.9 Purchases of property, plant and equipment (91.2) (54.0) Acquisitions, net of cash (0.2) — (Purchases of) proceeds from investments and other (0.1) 1.5 Net cash used in investing activities (90.1) (51.6) Cash flows from financing activities: Commercial paper borrowings 910.0 141.1 Commercial paper payments (724.0) (112.1) Payments on debt arrangements (11.5) (9.2) Payments of deferred financing costs — (1.7) Proceeds from employee stock purchases 2.6 2.6 Repurchases of common stock (151.3) (294.8) Repurchases of common stock to satisfy employee withholding tax obligations (11.4) (12.4) Cash dividends paid (90.5) (81.7) Net cash used in financing activities (76.1) (368.2) Increase (decrease) in cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash 21.9 (368.8) Effect of exchange rates on cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash equivalents (4.3) 2.9 Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash, beginning of period 52.7 415.1 Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash, end of period $ 70.3 $ 49.2 Supplemental disclosures of cash flow information: Interest paid $ 32.0 $ 19.6 Income taxes paid (net of refunds) $ 113.5 $ 44.0 The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements."},{"id":"e29","sourceId":"filing-2","location":"Liquidity / July 2026 Heat Controller acquisition","excerpt":"In July 2026, we acquired Heat Controller for approximately $205 million."},{"id":"e30","sourceId":"filing-3","location":"Executive compensation / long-term incentive metrics","excerpt":"Our long-term incentives generally include: (1) performance share units, which are designed to link compensation to the Company’s three-year financial performance as measured by return on invested capital and core net income growth; (2) stock appreciation rights, which are designed to incentivize NEOs to grow our business and deliver increased returns to our stockholders; and (3) restricted stock units, which are designed to support our retention efforts."},{"id":"e31","sourceId":"filing-3","location":"Compensation Discussion and Analysis / actual below-target annual payouts","excerpt":"In 2025, the Company’s achievement at target for the core net income goals and falling below target for cash flow and revenue resulted in below target level payouts under our annual STI Program for all NEOs."},{"id":"e32","sourceId":"filing-3","location":"Compensation Discussion and Analysis / earned PSU payout","excerpt":"In 2025, NEOs earned a payout of approximately 196% of target for the PSUs granted in December 2022."},{"id":"e33","sourceId":"filing-3","location":"Governance Highlights / independence, ownership guidelines and shareholder protections","excerpt":"The Board’s primary responsibility is the oversight of the Company’s management team, and the Board has a number of measures in place to continually enhance Board composition, efficiency, and effectiveness, demonstrated through the following: Independent Board Chair Mandatory Board Retirement age: 75 Majority Voting (with carve-out in case of contested elections) Key Committees 100% independent (Audit, Compensation, and Governance (nominating) Committees) No Directors Attended Less than 75% of Meetings Anti-Hedging and Pledging Policies Board is 89% independent (8 out of 9 directors) No Material Related-Party Transactions Regularly Scheduled Executive Sessions of non-management directors 3 Independent Board Members added in the last 2 yrs Women hold Board leadership positions (Governance (nominating) Committee & Audit Committee chairs) Succession Planning annually for key executives; CEO Succession Plan No Overboarding (directors not permitted to serve on more than four other public company boards) Stock Ownership Guidelines (5x retainer for Directors; 6x annual base salary for CEO; and 3x annual base salary for EVPs) Annual Self-Evaluation by the Board and its committees One Class of Voting Stock Individual evaluation for director nominees No Poison Pill Board Oversight The Board and its committees have oversight of important topics, as shown below, and are highly engaged in working through issues and discussing plans in both formal and informal meetings."},{"id":"e34","sourceId":"filing-10","location":"September 2026 award agreement / approved changes to vesting, exercise and retirement provisions","excerpt":"The terms of the Award Agreement are substantially similar to those in the form of award agreement previously disclosed by the Company, except for updates to the vesting and exercise schedules and retirement eligibility, as well as other administrative and conforming changes."},{"id":"e35","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"MD&A / annual operating-income comparison","excerpt":"•Operating income in 2025 was $1,042 million compared to $1,040 million in 2024."},{"id":"e36","sourceId":"filing-2","location":"MD&A / first-half Building Climate Solutions organic volume and acquisition growth","excerpt":"The following table presents our Building Climate Solutions segment's net sales and profit for the six months ended June 30, 2026 and 2025 (dollars in millions):\nDifference\n% Change\n252.0 \n250.9 \n179.4 \n71.5 \n% of net sales\n22.9 \n21.3 \nNet sales increased 30% for the six months ended June 30, 2026 as compared to the same period in 2025 primarily due to a 14% increase in sales volumes, a 10% increase in sales volumes from completed acquisitions, and 6% from favorable mix and price."},{"id":"e37","sourceId":"filing-3","location":"Corporate Governance / classified board terms","excerpt":"The size of our Board is currently fixed at nine members, divided into three classes, with each class serving a three-year term."},{"id":"e38","sourceId":"filing-1","location":"Independent auditor report / unqualified internal-control opinion","excerpt":"We also have audited, in accordance with the standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States) (PCAOB), the Company's internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2025, based on criteria established in Internal Control—Integrated Framework issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (2013 framework), and our report dated February 17, 2026 expressed an unqualified opinion thereon."},{"id":"e39","sourceId":"filing-11","location":"May 2026 director departure / board reduced to eight","excerpt":"In connection with Mr. Somasundaram’s departure, the Board has reduced the size of the Board from nine members to eight members."},{"id":"e40","sourceId":"filing-2","location":"Commitments and Contingencies / antitrust allegations","excerpt":"District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan on behalf of a putative class that alleges violations of Section 1 of the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890, as amended, and certain state laws."},{"id":"e41","sourceId":"filing-2","location":"Commitments and Contingencies / unresolved antitrust outcome","excerpt":"At this stage of the antitrust litigation, the Company cannot reasonably estimate the range of possible loss, if any, or the timing, outcome, or consequence of this litigation."},{"id":"e42","sourceId":"filing-13","location":"Carrier competitor disclosure / equipment and lifecycle service offerings","excerpt":"Products and controls, services, and systems include air conditioners, heat pumps, heating systems, home and building energy management systems, aftermarket components, repair and maintenance services and rentals as well as modernization and upgrades through the product lifecycle."}],"changes":["Retain the uncertain moat verdict: current channel, engineering and operating evidence still does not demonstrate durable economic protection.","Add contractual_freedom at grade 3 using supplied US sales terms, bounded by definitive-contract overrides and entity coverage.","Retain the previously assessed pricing and management grades after reassessing their arguments against current catalog passages.","Add bounded Carrier comparisons without attributing its capabilities or results to Lennox.","Do not carry forward unsupported ownership-compliance assumptions or treat September award-form approval as evidence of subsequent grants or vesting."],"limitations":["Named competitors are disclosed, but comparable dealer retention, market-share trends, unit costs and customer outcomes are absent. Carrier passages establish overlapping capabilities, not relative superiority.","Brand strength and product-efficiency leadership are issuer assertions; patents and engineering resources do not establish a durable premium.","Price and mix are generally combined. New-product mix, acquisitions, hedging, cost actions and tariff refunds limit attribution of profit resilience to pricing.","Retention is assessed indirectly from replacement demand, service activity and channel continuity; no issuer-specific renewal or dealer-retention rate is supplied.","The sales terms were retrieved October 19, 2026; that is not their publication or effective date. They cover Lennox Industries US goods sales, exclude affiliates with their own terms and yield to conflicting definitive contracts.","Actual executive holdings and ownership-guideline compliance are unavailable. The economic effect of the approved September award-form changes is not established.","Antitrust allegations remain unresolved and are not evidence of misconduct. Generic competitive and supply risks are possibilities, not proof of realized moat erosion."],"qualityAssessments":[{"category":"moat","checks":[{"criterion":"structural_advantage","grade":null,"rationale":"Direct distribution, parts access and engineering are established capabilities, but the passages do not establish superior costs, durable customer lock-in or an enduring premium.","evidenceIds":["e1","e2","e5","e9","e14"]},{"criterion":"durability","grade":null,"rationale":"Patents and trademarks support differentiation, but no single patent is material and no sustained customer or competitive outcome establishes the duration of economic protection.","evidenceIds":["e10","e11","e13"]},{"criterion":"customer_dependency","grade":null,"rationale":"National-account services and substantial direct-channel sales establish relationships, but channel share and replacement demand do not establish dependence on Lennox.","evidenceIds":["e3","e4","e20"]},{"criterion":"erosion_resilience","grade":null,"rationale":"Commercial growth offsets residential weakness, but mixed volumes and profitability do not distinguish durable structural resilience from operating and cyclical effects.","evidenceIds":["e6","e16","e18","e36"]}]},{"category":"pricing_power","checks":[{"criterion":"realized_pricing","grade":2,"rationale":"Favorable price/mix added 9% to 2025 sales and 5% to first-half 2026 sales. Management reports implemented pricing largely offset second-quarter inflation and tariff pressures. Annual benefits were primarily new-product mix, while organic volumes fell, limiting evidence of pure pricing power.","evidenceIds":["e12","e15","e16","e19"]},{"criterion":"retention","grade":2,"rationale":"Indirect operating evidence is mixed: replacement demand, national-account service growth and a broadly stable direct-channel mix support continued engagement. Residential volumes fell 16%. These outcomes do not identify customer defections or establish retention rates.","evidenceIds":["e4","e6","e20","e21"]},{"criterion":"margin_resilience","grade":2,"rationale":"In 2025, price/mix added 290 basis points against 280 basis points of product and distribution cost pressure. First-half 2026 gross margin fell 20 basis points and operating margin fell to 19.3% from 20.1%, despite $30 million of tariff refunds. Resilience is demonstrated but incomplete and cannot be attributed solely to pricing.","evidenceIds":["e17","e16","e18"]},{"criterion":"contractual_freedom","grade":3,"rationale":"Standard US goods terms allow quotation changes without notice and reserve price-adjustment rights at any time, including for increased costs. This is strong documented discretion within the terms' scope, subject to conflicting definitive contracts. It does not establish customer acceptance or equivalent rights across all subsidiaries and services.","evidenceIds":["e22","e23","e24"]}]},{"category":"strong_management","checks":[{"criterion":"capital_discipline","grade":2,"rationale":"Annual operating cash of $758 million supported $119 million of capital expenditure alongside $545 million of acquisition spending. First-half 2026 operating cash of $188.1 million accompanied $91.2 million of capital expenditure, $151.3 million of repurchases, $90.5 million of dividends and $186 million of net commercial-paper borrowing. July's $205 million acquisition adds deployment. Cash generation is demonstrated; acquisition returns and repurchase value creation remain unproven.","evidenceIds":["e25","e26","e27","e28","e29"]},{"criterion":"incentive_alignment","grade":3,"rationale":"Existing long-term incentives link three-year performance to ROIC and core-income growth. Actual annual payouts fell below target after cash-flow and revenue shortfalls, while a completed PSU cycle earned approximately 196% of target. Ownership guidelines and anti-hedging policies reinforce alignment. Actual holdings and guideline compliance are unavailable; approved September changes do not establish subsequent grants or vesting.","evidenceIds":["e30","e31","e32","e33","e34"]},{"criterion":"execution","grade":2,"rationale":"Assessed from operating outcomes: annual operating income was maintained despite a sales decline, and first-half 2026 operating income was broadly flat. Commercial organic volume rose 14%, while residential volume fell 16% and consolidated operating margin declined. This demonstrates mixed execution rather than proving management's claimed structural differentiation.","evidenceIds":["e12","e35","e16","e6","e36"]},{"criterion":"governance","grade":3,"rationale":"Disclosed practices include an independent chair, independent key committees, majority voting and no poison pill; an unqualified internal-control opinion supports reporting oversight. Classified terms constrain annual accountability. The proxy's eight-of-nine independence count predates the board's reduction to eight members. Unresolved antitrust allegations add uncertainty without establishing governance failure.","evidenceIds":["e33","e37","e38","e39","e40","e41"]}]}],"financialAssessments":[],"qualityPolicy":"quality-scores-2","sourcePolicy":"issuer-evidence-7","basisHash":"df611dbeb2a801a29fd089654cc8604b8bfeb347b57ae813dfacc150cdeb135a","updatedAt":"2026-10-19T21:10:20.173Z","sources":[{"id":"filing-1","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000028/lii-20251231.htm","publishedAt":"2026-02-17","sha256":"28649f50a62d01defd6ad0d64f4282fbe2d5cf5b7eec6b3b487a526c1e07f370","dateKind":"filed","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1"},{"id":"filing-2","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000087/lii-20260630.htm","publishedAt":"2026-07-29","sha256":"86bab3c4c6cdccaf066858afcba16d86e99012c89b73c4a40e6968bd04e8bdde","dateKind":"filed","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1"},{"id":"filing-3","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000046/lii-20260406.htm","publishedAt":"2026-04-08","sha256":"c303c56c8bfb51d1755a9d465119d3ff4d70003f0d0f2854d5c893af353d9b92","dateKind":"filed","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1"},{"id":"filing-4","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000162828025004859/lii-20241231.htm","publishedAt":"2025-02-11","sha256":"81957475910fa878fe7b4e196c6e29bb3af4c0f53cc31f649f565e60f9c543d7","dateKind":"filed","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1"},{"id":"filing-5","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000162828024004446/lii-20231231.htm","publishedAt":"2024-02-13","sha256":"34e690f362bfc5f3f7b548ddc2e19e0c613ef87a153367ba71732ddb32272d8f","dateKind":"filed","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1"},{"id":"filing-6","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000054/lii-20260331.htm","publishedAt":"2026-04-29","sha256":"5b5610b3819d5a39ebd2090e956c0dacba076c24e810deb5cf4818f4356be86a","dateKind":"filed","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1"},{"id":"filing-7","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000085/lii-20260630xexx991pressre.htm","publishedAt":"2026-07-29","sha256":"4efe73deec17856a7021604f4ec67688b98d927771912b52a0aa0ef17d479122","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed"},{"id":"filing-8","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000052/lii-20260331xexx991pressre.htm","publishedAt":"2026-04-29","sha256":"cee719b543c1806e2da053990340f0d8afb2ea82419462039bda912ae594dbfe","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed"},{"id":"filing-9","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000005/lii-20251231xexx991pressre.htm","publishedAt":"2026-01-28","sha256":"c8df4cf7a6b003444f7dc679f9bf9b2e23aeb3073df929e295f8e18dfd715756","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed"},{"id":"filing-10","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000091/lii-20260916.htm","publishedAt":"2026-09-18","sha256":"c36f892c8dc5b4f3e6148c7ea0ee218432dc1e1875b61e85508972e36b0d9570","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed"},{"id":"filing-11","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000076/lii-20260521.htm","publishedAt":"2026-05-28","sha256":"16bbb79287ee8b22968f28a87cf5f223c0e3e2e6dcb66a1aefcb980bdc541eaa","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed"},{"id":"filing-12","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920225000062/lii-20251204.htm","publishedAt":"2025-12-05","sha256":"1165fdcbc3a6f285a224018fb500236677a816c6cbac9c31f366136485814b93","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed"},{"id":"filing-13","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1783180/000178318026000008/carr-20251231.htm","publishedAt":"2026-02-05","sha256":"685b95802e121f1dfd459999028564d879f3086deae07624019b30f299a4aee2","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed","label":"CARRIER GLOBAL Corp annual report: competitor disclosure for comparison only. Its financial results, customer outcomes and advantages are not those of the subject issuer; compare only explicitly supported scope."},{"id":"filing-14","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1466258/000162828026005731/tt-20251231.htm","publishedAt":"2026-02-05","sha256":"6168469d22ddb32627f324aba56b2b850d63cc0c33b65fd7ef228ae1d5428237","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed","label":"Trane Technologies plc annual report: competitor disclosure for comparison only. Its financial results, customer outcomes and advantages are not those of the subject issuer; compare only explicitly supported scope."},{"id":"filing-15","url":"https://www.lennox.com/dA/f21eca2d22/fileAsset/Terms_and_Conditions_of_Sale%20-%20US.pdf?language_id=1","publishedAt":"2026-10-19","sha256":"10a57bc7dd7b0ab323a13d23708015f15e2c4d890d5abf3ff315dd7512ccd7cc","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"retrieved","label":"Lennox Industries US goods sales terms, excluding affiliates with their own terms; definitive signed contracts supersede conflicting standard terms"}],"model":"gpt-6.1-sol","providerId":"codex:20cbbe17de4d3aee24888a0b31bf2213f85d37e3a43cb96a48463fd031a34bf4","usage":{"input_tokens":173164,"cached_input_tokens":0,"cache_write_input_tokens":0,"output_tokens":4427,"reasoning_output_tokens":78}},"signals":[{"period":"2021","end":"2021-12-31","values":{"gross_margin":28.335042082926016,"operating_margin":14.074533272931019,"roic":55.02626190765055,"fcf_margin":9.744641281800623,"sbc_revenue":0.579385327006986},"issues":{"pfcf_growth":"TTM FCF per diluted share growth is zero or negative; a growth-adjusted multiple requires positive growth.","pb":"Equity attributable to owners is zero or negative, so this ratio is undefined.","software_capex":"Separately disclosed software and intangible investment is unavailable in the extracted statements for this period.","roe":"Average equity attributable to owners is zero or negative, so this ratio is undefined.","roic_wacc":"Enter a WACC assumption from 0 to 100%.","debt_equity":"Equity is zero or negative, so this ratio is undefined."}},{"period":"2022","end":"2022-12-31","values":{"gross_margin":27.227449983045105,"operating_margin":13.907256697185488,"roic":48.005129502378125,"fcf_margin":4.264157341471686,"sbc_revenue":0.462021024075958},"issues":{"pfcf_growth":"TTM FCF per diluted share growth is zero or negative; a growth-adjusted multiple requires positive growth.","pb":"Equity attributable to owners is zero or negative, so this ratio is undefined.","software_capex":"Separately disclosed software and intangible investment is unavailable in the extracted statements for this period.","roe":"Average equity attributable to owners is zero or negative, so this ratio is undefined.","roic_wacc":"Enter a WACC assumption from 0 to 100%.","debt_equity":"Equity is zero or negative, so this ratio is undefined."}},{"period":"2023","end":"2023-12-31","values":{"gross_margin":31.068467853630143,"operating_margin":15.8594110680664,"roic":45.173970645853004,"fcf_margin":9.755314237539896,"sbc_revenue":0.6041871575101869},"issues":{"software_capex":"Separately disclosed software and intangible investment is unavailable in the extracted statements for this period.","roic_wacc":"Enter a WACC assumption from 0 to 100%."}},{"period":"2024","end":"2024-12-31","values":{"gross_margin":33.17357197685957,"operating_margin":19.37356074363919,"roic":53.9880670599484,"fcf_margin":14.642502761500008,"sbc_revenue":0.5335779679104338},"issues":{"software_capex":"Separately disclosed software and intangible investment is unavailable in the extracted statements for this period.","roic_wacc":"Enter a WACC assumption from 0 to 100%."}},{"period":"2025","end":"2025-12-31","values":{"gross_margin":33.39171943872346,"operating_margin":20.046965526533597,"roic":41.06999471479466,"fcf_margin":12.295728831828768,"sbc_revenue":0.5601216484129886},"issues":{"pfcf_growth":"TTM FCF per diluted share growth is zero or negative; a growth-adjusted multiple requires positive growth.","software_capex":"Separately disclosed software and intangible investment is unavailable in the extracted statements for this period.","roic_wacc":"Enter a WACC assumption from 0 to 100%."}}],"sources":[{"id":"filing-1","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000028/lii-20251231.htm","publishedAt":"2026-02-17","sha256":"28649f50a62d01defd6ad0d64f4282fbe2d5cf5b7eec6b3b487a526c1e07f370","dateKind":"filed","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1"},{"id":"filing-2","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000087/lii-20260630.htm","publishedAt":"2026-07-29","sha256":"86bab3c4c6cdccaf066858afcba16d86e99012c89b73c4a40e6968bd04e8bdde","dateKind":"filed","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1"},{"id":"filing-3","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000046/lii-20260406.htm","publishedAt":"2026-04-08","sha256":"c303c56c8bfb51d1755a9d465119d3ff4d70003f0d0f2854d5c893af353d9b92","dateKind":"filed","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1"},{"id":"filing-4","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000162828025004859/lii-20241231.htm","publishedAt":"2025-02-11","sha256":"81957475910fa878fe7b4e196c6e29bb3af4c0f53cc31f649f565e60f9c543d7","dateKind":"filed","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1"},{"id":"filing-5","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000162828024004446/lii-20231231.htm","publishedAt":"2024-02-13","sha256":"34e690f362bfc5f3f7b548ddc2e19e0c613ef87a153367ba71732ddb32272d8f","dateKind":"filed","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1"},{"id":"filing-6","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000054/lii-20260331.htm","publishedAt":"2026-04-29","sha256":"5b5610b3819d5a39ebd2090e956c0dacba076c24e810deb5cf4818f4356be86a","dateKind":"filed","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1"},{"id":"filing-7","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000085/lii-20260630xexx991pressre.htm","publishedAt":"2026-07-29","sha256":"4efe73deec17856a7021604f4ec67688b98d927771912b52a0aa0ef17d479122","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed"},{"id":"filing-8","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000052/lii-20260331xexx991pressre.htm","publishedAt":"2026-04-29","sha256":"cee719b543c1806e2da053990340f0d8afb2ea82419462039bda912ae594dbfe","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed"},{"id":"filing-9","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000005/lii-20251231xexx991pressre.htm","publishedAt":"2026-01-28","sha256":"c8df4cf7a6b003444f7dc679f9bf9b2e23aeb3073df929e295f8e18dfd715756","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed"},{"id":"filing-10","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000091/lii-20260916.htm","publishedAt":"2026-09-18","sha256":"c36f892c8dc5b4f3e6148c7ea0ee218432dc1e1875b61e85508972e36b0d9570","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed"},{"id":"filing-11","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920226000076/lii-20260521.htm","publishedAt":"2026-05-28","sha256":"16bbb79287ee8b22968f28a87cf5f223c0e3e2e6dcb66a1aefcb980bdc541eaa","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed"},{"id":"filing-12","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1069202/000106920225000062/lii-20251204.htm","publishedAt":"2025-12-05","sha256":"1165fdcbc3a6f285a224018fb500236677a816c6cbac9c31f366136485814b93","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed"},{"id":"filing-13","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1783180/000178318026000008/carr-20251231.htm","publishedAt":"2026-02-05","sha256":"685b95802e121f1dfd459999028564d879f3086deae07624019b30f299a4aee2","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed","label":"CARRIER GLOBAL Corp annual report: competitor disclosure for comparison only. Its financial results, customer outcomes and advantages are not those of the subject issuer; compare only explicitly supported scope."},{"id":"filing-14","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1466258/000162828026005731/tt-20251231.htm","publishedAt":"2026-02-05","sha256":"6168469d22ddb32627f324aba56b2b850d63cc0c33b65fd7ef228ae1d5428237","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"filed","label":"Trane Technologies plc annual report: competitor disclosure for comparison only. Its financial results, customer outcomes and advantages are not those of the subject issuer; compare only explicitly supported scope."},{"id":"filing-15","url":"https://www.lennox.com/dA/f21eca2d22/fileAsset/Terms_and_Conditions_of_Sale%20-%20US.pdf?language_id=1","publishedAt":"2026-10-19","sha256":"10a57bc7dd7b0ab323a13d23708015f15e2c4d890d5abf3ff315dd7512ccd7cc","citationPolicy":"numeric-lines-1","dateKind":"retrieved","label":"Lennox Industries US goods sales terms, excluding affiliates with their own terms; definitive signed contracts supersede conflicting standard terms"}],"history":[{"version":8,"updatedAt":"2026-10-23T23:19:09.786Z","verdict":"uncertain","value":null},{"version":7,"updatedAt":"2026-10-22T23:12:09.520Z","verdict":"uncertain","value":null},{"version":6,"updatedAt":"2026-10-19T22:04:21.334Z","verdict":"uncertain","value":null},{"version":5,"updatedAt":"2026-10-19T18:33:29.802Z","verdict":"uncertain","value":null},{"version":4,"updatedAt":"2026-10-19T13:57:15.039Z","verdict":"uncertain","value":null},{"version":3,"updatedAt":"2026-10-18T16:35:43.872Z","verdict":"uncertain","value":null},{"version":2,"updatedAt":"2026-10-18T02:27:49.793Z","verdict":"uncertain","value":null},{"version":1,"updatedAt":"2026-10-18T02:18:02.026Z","verdict":null,"value":null}],"hasRequested":false,"requestStatus":"completed","researchIssue":null,"archivedMoat":null,"scope":"supported_catalog"}